Court Sides with NC over Alcoa Certification

A federal appeals court on Tuesday rejected an effort by an Alcoa Inc. subsidiary to speed up the federal license the company needs to operate dams on North Carolina’s Yadkin River for up to 50 more years.

The dams include the one that impounds High Rock Lake.

Alcoa and North Carolina officials are fighting over who will control the dams originally built to supply electricity to a now-closed aluminum plant that once employed hundreds in Badin.

The appeals court based in Washington, D.C., ruled against the company’s arguments that North Carolina water-quality regulators improperly issued a key certification.

Alcoa had asked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to proceed with relicensing, and when the commission declined, Alcoa challenged the decision.

The appeals court determined FERC could not issue a new operating license until the water-quality certification is granted.

“We are disappointed in the court’s ruling, and we will continue our efforts to obtain a federal license for the Yadkin project,” said Alcoa spokesman Mike Belwood.

Dean Naujoks, whose organization Yadkin Riverkeeper Inc. opposes relicensing, said it’s telling that Alcoa has lost in federal and state courts, the state legislature and other arenas.

“They do not legally deserve the right to obtain a license for another 50 years,” Naujoks said.

The water-quality certification came with the condition that Alcoa post bond guaranteeing $240 million in improvements bringing the dams up to water-quality standards.

The company’s four hydroelectric dams don’t currently meet standards as they draw deep water with low dissolved oxygen levels and discharge that water into the river.

State regulators have since revoked the certification to Alcoa Power Generating Inc. Administrative hearings last year revealed internal Alcoa emails that showed the company intentionally withheld information on the project’s ability to meet water quality standards, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources said in reaching that decision.

Full article originally appeared in the Salisbury Post.